I have a signed promissory note, but the borrower filed a consumer proposal — am I protected?
Holding a signed promissory note feels like protection — you did the responsible thing and got it in writing. So when the borrower files a consumer proposal, it's reasonable to ask whether that note keeps you safe. The honest answer is layered: the note is powerful in one specific way and powerless in another, and knowing the difference tells you exactly how much you can expect to recover.
First, what your promissory note is — and isn't
A promissory note is a written, signed promise to repay a defined sum on defined terms. It's a real, enforceable document, and having one puts you far ahead of a lender who has nothing. But a plain note is just that — a promise. It records that the debt exists; it doesn't, by itself, give you a claim against any specific piece of the borrower's property. In insolvency terms, that makes you an unsecured creditor: someone the borrower owes, but who has no direct hold over their assets.
That distinction is the whole game in a consumer proposal. The process draws a hard line between secured and unsecured creditors, and your note, unless it's tied to registered collateral, lands you on the unsecured side.
Secured vs unsecured — where your note sits
| Secured creditor | Has a registered legal interest in specific property (a mortgage, a lien, a PPSA-registered security). Their rights over that property are largely untouched by the proposal. |
| Unsecured creditor | Is owed money but has no claim on particular property. Bound by the proposal; shares proportionally in whatever it pays out. |
| A plain promissory note | Unsecured. Strong proof of the debt — but no priority over other unsecured creditors. |
So how does the proposal treat your note?
Like any unsecured debt. Once the borrower files, the automatic stay stops you from suing on the note or otherwise enforcing it directly. If the proposal is accepted by the required majority of creditors and approved by the court, it becomes binding on all unsecured creditors — including you, the note-holder, and including you even if you voted against it. You'll then receive a share of the proposal payments rather than the full face value of the note.
In other words: the promissory note doesn't shield you from the proposal. A borrower can include a noted debt in a proposal just as easily as a credit-card balance. What the note changes is not whether you're bound — it's how cleanly you can claim your share.
Where the note genuinely helps: proving your claim
To get anything out of a proposal, every unsecured creditor has to file a Proof of Claim with the Licensed Insolvency Trustee, and the claim has to stand up. This is exactly where the note earns its keep. A creditor with a vague "they owe me money" story can have their claim questioned or undervalued. A creditor holding a signed promissory note has a clean, dated, signed instrument stating the amount and terms — about the strongest evidence of a private debt you can bring.
The two things that actually beat a proposal
1. A secured note
If your note was backed by registered security — a mortgage on real property, or a security interest registered under your province's Personal Property Security Act — you're a secured creditor, and that's a different world. A consumer proposal deals with unsecured debt; it generally doesn't strip a valid secured creditor's rights in the underlying collateral. Most family and friend loans are not secured this way, which is precisely why the note alone leaves you unsecured. Whether a security interest was properly created and registered is a legal question worth confirming with a professional.
2. A co-signer or guarantor
This is the protection most people overlook. A consumer proposal binds the person who filed it — not anyone else who promised to pay. If your note was also signed by a co-signer or guarantor, that person's obligation generally survives the borrower's proposal. You can pursue the guarantor for the debt directly, in parallel with the proposal, because they're a separate party under a separate promise. A borrower's insolvency doesn't release the people who backed them.
This cuts both ways
If you co-signed or guaranteed a loan and the primary borrower files a proposal, you can still be on the hook for the whole amount — the lender can come to you. Being a guarantor is not a passive role.Putting it together: are you protected?
Partly, and it depends entirely on what kind of note you hold:
- Plain signed note (most common): you're an unsecured creditor, bound by the proposal, but with strong proof to file a full-value claim and collect your proportional share.
- Note with a co-signer or guarantor: you can pursue the other signer for the balance regardless of the borrower's proposal — often your best real recovery.
- Note backed by registered security: you're a secured creditor, and your rights in the collateral are largely preserved.
The lesson: a note is a floor, not a ceiling
A promissory note is genuinely worth having — it's the difference between a provable claim and an argument. But people often treat a note as full armour against non-payment, and a consumer proposal shows where that armour ends: it protects your ability to prove the debt, not your position in line. If protecting the money matters, the stronger setups are a full loan agreement with proper terms, registered security where the sum justifies it, or a co-signer. Our guides on promissory note vs loan agreement and whether a promissory note is enough compare the options, and you can build a complete loan agreement in minutes.
Make the next loan one you can actually enforce
A clear, signed agreement — who lent what, the repayment terms, both e-signatures — is the record that proves your claim if it ever lands in court or an insolvency. Free to draft.
Create my loan agreement →- Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, RSC 1985, c. B-3 — Division II, s. 66.28 (binding on unsecured creditors), s. 69.2 (stay), treatment of secured vs unsecured claims
- Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB) — You Are Owed Money: Consumer Proposals (Government of Canada)
- OSB — Form 31, Proof of Claim